Neulander actually starts to hold Leslie’s system nearby, from the shower and you may on Jenna’s consider

They hold their mother so you can a place best away from restroom and you may Jenna claims it is at that time, she requires a cordless mobile out of the girl mother’s dressing area, and reconnects towards 911 driver

Fitzpatrick thinks Jenna drops the device together with call catches, seconds after, the specific time when she first observes their mother: while the Dr. It’s upcoming she lets reduce a cry away from absolute pain:

“Since the bland since it is to learn, it’s inconceivable one to one call is anything besides an effective declaration out-of guilt against the girl dad,” told you Fitzpatrick.

Nevertheless the defense claims a comparable label proves Dr. Neulander’s innocence –whenever Jenna incurs the toilet, there isn’t any blood on wall space but really. Jenna testifies she sees the telephone of the toilet, falls they as it is not performing when you find yourself racing to simply help this lady dad. Regarding the safety evaluate, this is how Jenna notices blood for the, and you will doing, the girl mother. This is where she yells, “You will find blood every where. “

“The defense’s accept that is you to their mom exists, facing the lady, and you will she actually is responding so you can her mom, new blood that is on her mom and possibly blood toward wall surface as well as on the floor also,” said Stevens.

“You to definitely aids the idea the first time she watched blood, she is looking at the woman mother,” Axelrod listed in order to Stevens.

The latest D.A beneficial, even when, will not believe Jenna you will do everything she states have inked within the thirteen mere seconds the 911 label try toward hold. Fitzpatrick tried it himself and says they grabbed your about fifty moments.

There clearly was others part of Jenna’s testimony which are often very important. She informs the latest jury you to definitely because the woman dad are tending to her mommy on rooms, she saw your cut off a bloodstream-soaked shirt and you can place it to the side. Today think about, the new safety ideal one tossing so it soft clothing may have triggered some of the blood splatter on the bedroom. But the top is never located.

“She would state no,” Fitzpatrick told you. “I do not think inside her head Jenna believes that the lady father did that it. I believe she’s written a safety business inside her notice in which mom tucked and you may dropped about bath.”

“I am concerned they are that have an emotional response to the brand new heartache with the woman. . They know that this lady wishes them to vote simple. Plus they know that so it 60-plus-year-dated offender is impractical so you can reoffend,” Fitzpatrick explained. “And all sorts of those individuals attitude can enjoy toward hindrance out of case one is proven past a reasonable question.”

The Verdict

Just after eight difficult days of testimony, Section Lawyer Costs Fitzpatrick handled the fresh new jury one final time to own closing arguments, inquiring them to seriously consider the new real evidence — especially the fresh new blood splatter with the structure while the injuries to help you Leslie Neulander’s looks.

“As i told you repeatedly regarding the trial, Leslie often talk to your, female and you will men. You must tune in to her,” the guy advised Axelrod. “Also to plus tune in cautiously into the terms and conditions regarding Jenna Neulander where critical 911 label.”

But there is anything the new D.Good. could not give the brand new jury: just what he candidates was the brand new reason one sent Robert Neulander towards the a great murderous rage you to day. Investigators discovered away from a buddy of your Neulander nearest and dearest one Leslie is thinking of signing a lease having another type of flat for the your day she passed away.

“Leslie is on her behalf way out. And this refers to perhaps not one that can handle one to,” Fitzpatrick told Axelrod.